It’s impossible to do anything related to The Lord of the Rings without the long shadow of J.R.R. Tolkien hanging over it. It’s natural. He’s the creator and his influence over all later fantasy is tremendous. That’s why it’s inevitable that, when adapting any of his works, it’s hard for his presence not to make itself felt in a very noticeable way. And many times, it’s hard to live up to him. But the creators of The Rings of Power have found a powerful ally in his family: his grandson Simon.
A family member making sure his legacy is respected
Patrick McKay, one of the key people behind the series, said in an interview with Slash Film that his role in the series is much more important than just a consultant. “Simon is like that person you call when you need help. We’re in constant contact with him. He questions some things, we push back on him too… We’re very fortunate to work with Simon. He’s a real asset to the series,” thus confirming the crucial role he plays in The Rings of Power.
Something that stands out because, if there’s one thing the series has been systematically criticized for, it’s its changes to the original work. While it doesn’t strictly adapt a book, it does adapt a series of stories written by Tolkien. And the fact that it has the approval not only of the Tolkien Society, but that the writer’s grandson is also there giving it the green light and vetoing certain changes and aspects of it, shows that care is being taken to be as faithful as possible to the author’s original idea.
They have stressed this by saying that “we’re lucky to work with great people who know Tolkien, his mythology, and his literature, in addition to all those extraordinary professionals in the film industry”. Not just Simon. Perhaps suggesting that some fans take purism too far.