Rockstar seems to have triumphed with GTA 6. There is universal enthusiasm among the press, which has given it absolutely incredible reviews, and an audience devoted to the game, both in their own playthroughs and on streams. Not that this means some critical voices aren’t already emerging. Which is surprising because they aren’t coming from where we’d expect. The first serious criticism we’ve heard of its release has come from a video game legend, Warren Spector, creator of Deus Ex, saying he hopes that “GTA 6 is the last of its kind”.
A man with an idea of what the industry should be like
The reason is that, as he explains in a LinkedIn post, “its multibillion-dollar development cost and an undoubtedly enormous marketing budget don’t represent a business model that anyone else can—or probably should—imitate. This is especially true when thousands of developers are out of work”. He argues that this is a model that does nothing but harm the medium.
From his perspective, “a billion dollars can pay for a lot of games and a lot of salaries. Personally, I’d rather have hundreds of games and full employment than a single game, however incredible it may be”. And that’s why he’d prefer lots of different games to another GTA.
But that doesn’t mean he doesn’t give the game its due. He also believes GTA 6 is an example of how “if you give a game the time and money it needs to demonstrate its potential (the key word is “potential”), you’ll have the chance to create something great”. But likewise, “underfunding it or forcing it out before it’s ready guarantees failure, however much potential it has”. Something he has experience with, since his latest game, Thick As Thieves, has been a failure precisely because of these two problems: being underfunded and being forced to release it early.
Hence, while it may seem that Spector is criticizing the game’s release, he’s actually calling for a healthier, more stable industry. One in which it’s possible for games and developers to have all the time and money they need and in which absurd amounts aren’t spent on making a single game. Even if that shows how, indeed, sparing no expense helps make a good game.