GTA 6 review-bombing dispute spreads: Zelda’s score falls to 8.9
Grand Theft Auto VI (GTA 6) was released on November 19, and its Metacritic user score has reportedly slipped to 5.4/10 amid a run of zero-score reviews. Critics gave it 99/100 on the same site.
The user score has reportedly moved between 5.0 and 5.6, far below the ratings on console stores. On PlayStation, GTA 6 sits at 4.83–4.84/5 from roughly 170,000 ratings; Xbox users have given it 4.9/5. Those purchase-linked ratings provide a comparison, though they don’t prove anyone manipulated the Metacritic score. And the critics’ 99 ties the original 1998 The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time rather than beating it.
The dispute appears to have spilled over to The Legend of Zelda’s Switch 2 remake. On November 21, apparent retaliatory reviews reportedly pushed its Metacritic user score from 9.6 to 8.9. That put Clair Obscur: Expedition 33, with 9.4, back at the top of Metacritic’s all-time user rankings.
“Take your own medicine,” one review read. That comment doesn’t establish that Zelda fans started the dispute, which has also touched on the games’ reported Game of the Year nomination counts: eight versus four.
For anyone deciding whether either game is worth downloading, the complaints deserve a closer look than the averages alone. GTA players cite the 30fps target, frame-rate drops, crashes, pricing and lack of a PC launch. Others object to its life-simulation mechanics or content they consider “woke.” Zelda complaints focus on older design, simplified puzzles, pricing and resolution.
No independent audit has separated those complaints from other motives. There’s also no reported response from Metacritic, Rockstar Games or Nintendo, and calls to scrap user scores leave those questions unanswered.
GTA 6 is available on PlayStation and Xbox. PC players don’t have a launch version.
Author: Jesús Bosque
{
"de-DE": "Ich bin Journalist mit über 30 Jahren Erfahrung in Videospielen und Technologie. Obwohl Videospiele schon immer mein Fachgebiet waren, habe ich begonnen, auch die komplexen Strukturen von Projektmanagement-Tools wie Asana sowie die Automatisierungen mit Make.com und N8N zu entdecken und zu genießen.",
"en-US": "I’m a journalist with more than 30 years of experience in video games and technology. Although my specialty has always been video games, I’ve recently started enjoying exploring the intricacies of project-management tools like Asana, as well as automations with Make.com and N8N.",
"es-ES": "Soy periodista con más de 30 años de experiencia en videojuegos y tecnología. Aunque mi especialidad siempre ha sido el videojuego, he empezado a disfrutar también de descubrir los laberintos de los programas de project management como Asana y las automatizaciones de make.com y de N8N",
"fr-FR": "Je suis journaliste avec plus de 30 ans d’expérience dans le jeu vidéo et la technologie. Bien que ma spécialité ait toujours été le jeu vidéo, j’ai commencé à prendre plaisir à explorer également les méandres des outils de gestion de projet comme Asana, ainsi que les automatisations avec Make.com et N8N.",
"it-IT": "Sono un giornalista con oltre 30 anni di esperienza nei videogiochi e nella tecnologia. Anche se la mia specialità è sempre stata il videogame, ho iniziato a divertirmi anche a scoprire i meccanismi degli strumenti di project management come Asana e delle automazioni con Make.com e N8N.",
"ja-JP": "",
"nl-NL": "Ik ben een journalist met meer dan 30 jaar ervaring in videogames en technologie. Hoewel videogames altijd mijn specialiteit zijn geweest, ben ik ook begonnen te genieten van het verkennen van de ingewikkelde wereld van projectmanagementtools zoals Asana en van automatiseringen met Make.com en N8N.",
"pl-PL": "Jestem dziennikarzem z ponad 30-letnim doświadczeniem w grach wideo i technologii. Choć moją specjalizacją zawsze były gry wideo, ostatnio zacząłem również czerpać przyjemność z odkrywania zawiłości narzędzi do zarządzania projektami, takich jak Asana, oraz automatyzacji w Make.com i N8N.",
"pt-BR": "Sou jornalista com mais de 30 anos de experiência em videogames e tecnologia. Embora meu foco sempre tenha sido os videogames, recentemente passei a gostar de explorar também os labirintos de ferramentas de gestão de projetos como o Asana e das automações com Make.com e N8N.",
"social": {
"email": "jesus.bosque@softonic.com",
"facebook": "",
"twitter": "",
"linkedin": ""
}
}
View all posts by Jesús Bosque