Villanova University has published a new study in Judgment and Decision Making with a result plenty of writers probably won’t enjoy: in blind ratings, machine-written short stories scored higher than human-written ones on both absorbing and quality. The responses came from more than 1,600 readers.
A follow-up test with more than 900 participants found that readers could identify the machine-written story at about the rate you’d expect from random guessing, though text generator experience were better at spotting it. Lead researcher Dr. Deena Skolnick Weisberg said one reason may be that simpler, easier-to-process prose helps these stories move more smoothly on the page.
That changed once labels were added. When a story was described as human-written, it got higher scores no matter who wrote it. That lines up with a 2024 Bynder survey in which 56% of readers picked the machine-written article when reading blind, and with separate 2026 findings suggesting that news produced by a person using software was seen as more trustworthy than copy generated entirely by a machine.
If you follow AI writing, this study is worth reading because it gets at the same issue now showing up in publishing disputes, including the Commonwealth Short Story Prize controversy over entries flagged as machine-generated.
You can read the study in Judgment and Decision Making.
Author: Gerard Patrick Cadiang
{
"social": {
"email": "content.reviewer67@ext.softonic.com",
"facebook": "",
"twitter": "",
"linkedin": ""
},
"ja-JP": "",
"de-DE": "Gerard Cadiang ist Schriftsteller, 3D-Künstler und Spieleentwickler, der Softwarebesprechungen und Videospiele mit technischer Präzision und kreativem Scharfsinn behandelt.",
"en-US": "Gerard Cadiang is a writer, 3D artist, and game developer who covers software reviews and video games. He wields the skills of a writer in constant flux between technical precision and creative whimsy.",
"es-ES": "Gerard Cadiang es escritor, artista 3D y desarrollador de videojuegos que aborda reseñas de software y videojuegos con precisión técnica e ingenio creativo.",
"fr-FR": "Gerard Cadiang est un écrivain, artiste 3D et développeur de jeux vidéo qui traite les critiques de logiciels et les jeux vidéo avec une précision technique et une fantaisie créative.",
"it-IT": "Gerard Cadiang è uno scrittore, artista 3D e sviluppatore di videogiochi che affronta recensioni software e videogiochi con precisione tecnica e estro creativo.",
"nl-NL": "Gerard Cadiang is een schrijver, 3D-kunstenaar en game developer die softwarereviews en videogames behandelt met technische precisie en creatieve vindingrijkheid.",
"pl-PL": "Gerard Cadiang to pisarz, artysta 3D i twórca gier, który zajmuje się recenzjami oprogramowania i grami wideo z precyzją techniczną i kreatywnym kunsztem.",
"pt-BR": "Gerard Cadiang é escritor, artista 3D e desenvolvedor de jogos que aborda análises de software e videogames com precisão técnica e criatividade inovadora."
}
View all posts by Gerard Patrick Cadiang
