Toy Story is a franchise that generates tremendous nostalgia. Its first three films were a tremendous success and the fifth has managed to rekindle the spark. That’s why it’s no surprise that over at Atari they wanted to bring back the franchise’s video games. A collection called Toy Story Retro Roundup! and, separately, Toy Story 3 Complete Edition. But how are these games? Have they aged well? That’s what we’re going to talk about, looking at them one by one.
Toy Story
The first Toy Story game is a decent platformer that, while not brilliant, has held up well over time. Of the Mega Drive, Super Nintendo, and Game Boy Color versions, unless you have a particular attachment to one version, the Mega Drive one is the best of the three: it was the main version and it shows. The Game Boy version has charm, but it isn’t great. And the best we can say about the game is that it reproduces the original film very faithfully.
A Bug’s Life
For some reason they’ve included the A Bug’s Life game in this collection, but we’re not going to complain. Much. With only the PlayStation and Game Boy Color versions included, and the Nintendo 64 and PC ones left out, this is a game that has historically been vilified, and not without reason. The handheld version is quite terrible, but the PlayStation one has a certain charm if you know exactly what you’re getting into: a somewhat obtuse platformer that, at times, is so faithful to the film that it ends up being harder than it should be.
Toy Story 2
Toy Story 2 only came out for Game Boy Color and it’s a side-scrolling platformer that didn’t make much of an impact when it came out. It’s not hard to see why today. Very limited, very unoriginal, it has a certain charm if you’re a Toy Story fan, but that’s about all it has going for it.
Toy Story 2: Buzz Lightyear to the Rescue
Probably the most divisive of the games in the compilation and included here only in its PlayStation version. A mix of platformer and action game, it’s a game with a questionable frame rate, a camera that could use improvement and a limited number of NPCs and lines of dialogue from them. But if you’re able to look past those problems, typical of games of the time, the result is a game well worth championing, one that knew how to capture the charm of the film and expand it gracefully. It’s not Super Mario 64 or Rayman 2, but within the 3D platformers of the time it does a good job.
Buzz Lightyear of Star Command
Unfortunately we can’t say the same about its next game. Because although Buzz Lightyear of Star Command is another platformer and action game, this time based on the Buzz Lightyear animated series, it doesn’t feel as fluid and inspired as the previous game. The Game Boy Color version, also present in the collection, is rather clumsy and fails to capture the concept’s potential charm, but it’s also a very late game for the console: by then, developers had already moved on.
Toy Story Racer
What if Mario Kart were Toy Story? You’d get this unmemorable, but decent racing game where more attention is paid to detail than you might expect. It’s not Mario Kart, but it can compete with the other kart games of the time that were trying to ride Nintendo’s coattails. Holding up surprisingly well even today, both the PlayStation version and the Game Boy version still feel fresh and interesting now. Reminding us that, in another era, not everything was Mario Kart.
Toy Story 3
Originally released on Wii, Nintendo DS, PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360, it’s the most celebrated game of them all. So much so that it’s sold separately or in a pack with the others, but not in the same collection. The reason is that it’s a modern 3D platformer, in the vein of Little Big Planet, with great attention to detail and great care taken to make it look like an animated film. Charming, fun and satisfying to play, it’s a game that brings back a lot of nostalgia for Toy Story fans… and that’s only natural. But that’s what this collection is about. The affection we feel for all these toys.




