Oshi no Ko is the most popular anime of the season, if not the entire year, but that doesn’t mean it has managed to evade the controversies that such sensitive material from the original manga could bring. Depression, bullying, murder, and sex play significant roles in the original work, portraying the entertainment industry as a particularly shady business with dark and dichotomous interests. However, it is possible that when developing one of its storylines, the anime’s writers took the similarities to reality too far.
The sixth and seventh episodes of the series focused on the recording of a reality show featuring the main characters, where one of the characters, young Akane Kurokawa, is portrayed as the villain. This leads to her experiencing relentless online harassment, which is explicitly depicted on screen, causing her to contemplate suicide. While Akane eventually recovers and overcomes the situation, the problem is that the messages and the situation bear a striking resemblance to a real-life situation: that of Hana Kimura.
Hana Kimura was a 22-year-old professional wrestler who, in September 2019, joined the fifth season of the reality show Terrace House. There, in an episode filmed in early January 2020, she had a trivial conflict with a housemate, which was magnified by the show’s hosts. When the episode aired in March, she experienced an exceptionally severe case of cyberbullying, which led to depression and tragically ended in Hana taking her own life in 2020.
This resemblance has led many people on the internet to comment on the similarities between Hana’s situation and the messages she endured, and those that Akane faces in the series. One particularly prominent voice in this discussion is that of Kyoko Kimura, Hana’s mother. Expressing her lament that the circumstances of her daughter’s life were used for an anime storyline, she publicly criticized what had been done, and the internet erupted. Numerous fans of the series took to cyberbullying Kyoko Kimura, and this behavior continues to this day. Neither the animation studio responsible for the series, Doga Kobo, nor the publisher behind the original work, Shueisha, have yet made any statements regarding the possible influence of Hana’s story on Akane’s character or the fans’ behavior in response to Kyoko Kimura’s statements.
This silence is tarnishing the image of Oshi no Ko. While a live-action adaptation is planned for the series, its production will remain halted as long as the controversy surrounding Hana Kimura persists. This silence benefits no one involved. Nor does the harassment from fans who fail to grasp the true message of the series they claim to love.
Meanwhile, Hana Kimura’s legacy lives on. On May 23rd, marking the third anniversary of her passing, the Hana Kimura Memorial “pinx!” event was held for the third consecutive year to pay tribute to her. The event showcased what she loved most in this world: the best of puroresu, or Japanese wrestling. Available to watch on Fite TV, all proceeds from this event held at the Korakuen Hall in Tokyo, Japan were donated to the anti-cyberbullying association led by Kyoko, Hana’s mother, called Remember Hana.
While it’s true that Oshi no Ko continues to achieve success after success, including its opening dominating charts worldwide, that doesn’t excuse the fact that controversy is casting a dark shadow over the anime. And it will continue to do so until its creators address this issue in a serious and decisive manner. They need to clarify whether the events are inspired by Hana or not, issue an apology if necessary, and make it clear that their stance is not reflective of their fans. Because sometimes, silence only amplifies the pain. This is something that all individuals who have experienced harassment, like Akane and Hana, understand all too well.
Some of the links added in the article are part of affiliate campaigns and may represent benefits for Softonic.
With YouTube, there is a golden rule: Do not read the comments section.
